I’m giving 4 stars, because i think that is hard for anything to be perfect. But i can say that it is the best book so far that i’ve read till now, engaging great history maybe beyond the imagination of someone. Chapters talking about the Island takes you to a summer feeling place with love, stories told by the tree makes you wondering with your imagination, and talking about the history and tradition by the members of family of characters it’s something mixed really good. The end of the book is something that makes you wondering if you have to feel good or bad for the main character.