I am not a fan Roger Waters. I think he is a political hack and a bitter old man and I have to be honest and tell you that I only listened to two and a half tracks when I decided I couldn't stomach any more. To obliterate the work of your old bandmates under the guise of "re-imagining the album how I originally conceived it" is, to my mind, utter rubbish, Yes my view is not unbiased but seriously, it actually sounds to my ears that the man has projected himself so much into the music that it has become like him. Old, tired, rehashed, and no longer relevant. The fact that the vocal recording is pristine (me, me, me, again) is why I give it one star. If I could It would be 0.