Xiaolong Huang

While I haven't had the opportunity to read the original book, my interest in sci-fi drew me to explore "The Three-Body Problem" series, particularly for its intriguing exploration of extraterrestrial contact. I appreciate its narrative that ambitiously delves into the scientific, philosophical, socio-economic, and existential dimensions of such an encounter. However, I felt that the stories, scenes, and conversations lacked depth and coherence compared to the scope it tackles. The character interactions, for instance, lacked memorability, diminishing the story's impact. Moreover, the portrayal of characters, especially scientists, occasionally struck me as lacking in sophistication and depth, which seemed at odds with their professional backgrounds. From a scientific standpoint, the series hinges on a few critical concepts that, while central to the plot, appear either incorrect or highly improbable. This approach detracts from the 'hard science fiction' essence, seemingly exploring their entertainment values rather than offering a rigorous exploration of the subject matter. Overall, the employment of those sciences seems to be forced and superficial. Narratively, certain scenes and conversations felt shallow, failing to advance the storyline or carry real or deep meanings they pretentiously attempt to. Additionally, the CGI quality did not meet the expectations set by contemporary standards in the genre. While the first half of the series captured my interest more effectively, the latter segments seemed to lose momentum, affecting the overall engagement with the story. Despite these criticisms, the series' attempt to weave a multifaceted narrative around extraterrestrial contact is commendable, offering some intriguing and entertaining moments.