I've seen all of HIMYM and thought it was funny. Of course it has its flaws but I would give it 4 stars. As far as HIMYF I went in thinking they can't remake the original but make a different version with a new twist. It should be funny though right? That's what I thought. The humor is very dry. Very lacking in the relationships between friends and theres no depth to the story. I watched 4 episodes trying to give it a chance but every time lost interest. For Hilary's ( sorry don't know her characters name) love interest in the guys she comes across is so dull.