Following from the focused, kinetic action of The Raid and then its even more ambitious, sprawling gangster epic follow up, Gareth Evans sets his sights on a new genre and a new setting, but applies the same, razor sharp directorial focus that defined those films. Apostle is clearly rooted in religious horror but its ambition is also its undoing, sending it, slowly, in several dead end, cinematic directions.
The desperation of the early 20th century remote community on a verge of starvation is palpable and Apostle has the kind of muted but deliberate colour palette that allows green to pop and blood run in thick black, crimson rather that slasher red. The setting is intriguing, obviously evocative of very recent, successful The VVitch. Dropped into an isolated island of religious cultist is Thomas, in search of his kidnapped sister and himself, clearly unstable, if somewhat ingenious. He's a survivor and his initial quest is a tense cat and mouse game. Shame that it soon falls prey to clichés and short cuts that dilute its impact. He will be saved by coincidence, and rarely give the story any momentum.
Too often it feels that visuals are only servicing the film's horror connotations and ultimately Apostle becomes a victim of its broad, meandering script that can't match Evans' keen eye for setting up grizzly, wonderful images and set-pieces. He's perhaps not critical enough of his own script.
This bloat was less obvious in The Raid 2, but that film also ran for a cruel two hours plus. Apostle has ironically, too many ideas and not enough plot to propel it forward with enough momentum and many viewers will find the many segues from Thomas' initial investigation to be dulling its punch. Though it has to be said that one of the film's most effective and most gruesome moments happens without his involvement.
It's a shame because Dan Stevens brings the same, steely eyed intensity that he did to his role in another genre hit The Guest, but here successfully manages a measure of vulnerability that serves the film well. Everyone else is at least efficient but dialogue betrays some of the dramatic moments with several misjudged lines. “Your eyes, they've seen things” Thomas hears at one point with portent that doesn't seem to belong in the desperate landscape that Evans build.
Ultimately the ideas behind Apostle fuel a B-movie that could easily operate without the forced gravitas that permeates it. It's The Wicker Man by the way of gory grand-guignol that hopes to elevate itself through its deployment of religious zealots, pagan deities and broken humans, all unknowingly, but suspiciously heading towards a cruel new century of true horrors. It's too unfocused but still filled with powerful images that are sure to hold the attention of genre aficionados.