Basit Ali

1. She wrote about some personalities disrespectfully, which is common among westerners as they don't figure out how Muslim think about Islamic personalities. 2. Some of the stories mentioned are based on weak and unauthentic sources as we Muslims believe on early sources, hadiths. She should have taken hadiths as source 3. An author shouldn't be judgemental in his views, which I believe Lesley were in some points