TLDR: Jennifer Connelly and the wlw storylines were the only interesting parts of this show but they scrapped both of those things very quickly into the second season and now it’s just a boring mess so yeah i stopped watching. Its extremely long scenes of meaningless dialogue after dialogue and camera shots of peoples faces for way too long for literally no reason. Guy presses a button and oh let’s show the audience his facial reaction to pressing a button for 5 minutes. Feels like a complete waste of time
Im generously giving it 2 stars because some episodes in season 1 were enjoyable to watch, despite the awful editing that lingers on peoples faces too long and predictable storyline. I already had doubts about the show from the first episode because I could already tell that Josie was going to be a shallow character whose entire personality hinges on Layton and mothering children. I was pleasantly surprised the few times she got scenes that did not revolve around Layton or the kid.
Season 2 went quickly downhill for me from the huge push on motherhood to the huge emphasis on the pregnancy storyline. In addition the characters were written into “cliques” where they only ever interact with the same people every single scene. How many times do I have to watch Layton and Zarah discussing their pregnancy like be fr. Who cares what they name their child. Why does it feel like so many scenes are dedicated to irrelevant stuff like this but you scrap the only wlw relationship in the whole show and don’t replace it with another. Like okay, Till becomes a detective, so why not have her interrogate hot women potential love interests that turn out to be the killer or something instead of going to a freaking pastor and talking about church like wtf. I’m not mad or offended, I’m disappointed cause there were so many better ways to write this character and the writers chose the most boring way. I was so sure the writers were building something between Melanie and Audrey from the way Audrey first hated her and seemed to be holding a grudge but seemed to come around and even comfort Melanie when she finally goes for her therapy session that was one of the only times in the entire show we get to see Melanie actually bonding with a woman that isn’t her child but no, shortly after, Melanie gets thrown off the train and Audrey gets to be Mr.Woldorf’s personal prostitute. That’s the biggest wasted opportunity I’ve ever seen in any show ever.
In addition to cutting Melanie, the hottest most likeable character on the show out of the plot, who tf asked for a budding romance between Ostwald and the girl that collects penises and honestly why? Wouldn’t it have been more interesting if Ostwald who sexually exploited a guy in season 1 went to the janitor begging for a job that would have been a prime opportunity for the janitor to sexually exploit Ostwald and Ostwald could finally grow and learn how it feels to be sexually exploited while in need. Just so many missed opportunities… did they switch writers in season 2 or something? Or did they conduct a survey and find only republicans watch their show or something idk LOL but if you read all this, it’s an L from me