Fantasy Island" has been met with mixed reviews, and one of the prevailing criticisms revolves around its convoluted plot and inconsistent tone. The film attempts to blend horror and fantasy elements but often falls short of creating a cohesive and engaging narrative. Some viewers found the storyline to be predictable and lacking in depth, with characters making irrational decisions that defy logic. Additionally, the movie has been faulted for its reliance on clichés and generic tropes, failing to offer a fresh or innovative take on the premise. While the concept of a mystical island that fulfills people's fantasies holds promise, many argue that the execution in this particular film leaves much to be desired, resulting in a disappointing viewing experience for some audiences.