Mr. Trackmaster

This movie is HORRIBLE. There are so many unrealistic elements in it, it tries to do a hundred different things at once to be exciting, which ironically makes it come off as uninteresting, the new characters either suck or are pointless, the segments where Thomas is in the international countries are boring, and the writing is awful. 2/10. Would not recommend.

Journey Beyond Sodor has a great plot, quite a few interesting characters, and solid action. However, there are a lot of things that drag it down, too. There are unrealistic elements GALORE, from the engines' body gestures to Thomas somehow being able to avoid being able to be dropped into a vat of lava and driving on a pipe- it's messy. Theo and Lexi are very annoying characters, (specifically the latter), the ending is HORRIBLE, and the songs are hit-or-miss. 5/10. I can't decide if I would recommend this or not. It's a hard choice.

A LOT of work needed to be done here. A very exciting premise executed pretty badly is the main issue here, and the first two-thirds of the movie are very unengaging, but the Great Railway Show segment is fun, just rushed. The songs are also great too. 4/10. Wouldn't really recommend.

The best Thomas movie EVER! Jaw-dropping animation, beautiful music, and an incredibly engaging plot. The action is awesome, Thomas is portrayed completely correctly, and it is overall a very cinematic movie- even more so than the franchise's actual cinematic release. 10/10. I can't recommend this enough!

An amazing tribute to Wilbert Awdry's writings, with charming and heartwarming moments throughout, and one of the best climaxes in the show. The characters could use some fixing, but the movie is ASTOUNDING nonetheless. A brilliant retelling of the Railway Series. 9/10. Would definitely recommend!

While I have a ton of nostalgia for it, I can't overlook its flaws. It has a very messy plot, doesn't feel like a real special, and the animation isn't great. But the four plots strung together are interesting nonetheless. Stephen is a great character, with some very good dialogue. The plot of the castle being restored is cool, even if predictable, and the rest of the movie is very charming. 6/10. Would recommend.

The best thing to come out of the Miller era! A very surprisingly good movie, with an interesting plot, great character development, stellar action, and the return of the narrow gauge engines, who are finally in character after years of being showcased as idiotic children. 9/10. Would DEFINITELY recommend!

While Hiro's backstory and Spencer's motives for wanting Hiro scrapped are unclear, the movie is a very enjoyable watch, with a nice plot and great new characters, specifically Hiro and Victor. The writing is a bit lazy, and the narrator talks way too much, but still worth your time. 7/10. Would recommed.

A wonderful love letter to Thomas and Friends' model series. Impressive props, stellar action, and a fun plot. Pierce Brosnan's narration can sometimes drag, as well as the middle of the movie, but definitely worth your time. 8/10. Would definitely recommend!