This is NOT for everyone. First, it helps if you find Peyton and Eli funny regardless of the setting. I enjoy their brotherly banter, their football acumen and I think they are really nice guys. Second, if you are super focused on every play of the game, forget it. Tune into the traditional cast. Third, their guests are top notch. However, some of the guests perform much better or much worse than you might expect. Ryan Fitzpatrick and John McEnroe were great. Tracey Morgan was horrible. The Mannings and their guests also talk over each other and talk over key plays in the game. All of the above make this a five star experience. It’s interesting, largely unscripted and completely unpredictable. It’s reality TV with wit and intelligence. Not going back to the traditional broadcast…..the Manning boys are the best.