To be honest, I think bf5 is a really good game. I would still recommend bf1 over bf5. It's a great first-person shooter with a huge map full of details, easter eggs, and secrets. I would recommend this game but if you don't have bf1 I would get that first. Then if you like that, consider bf5. The new War in the Pacific made the game a huge step up. I agree some of the weapons and vehicles aren't historically accurate, but other than that, good game. I rate it a 7/10