I’m still mystified that critics were so harsh on this film. We watched it the other night, the Director’s Cut, and loved it just like we’ve done over the years since 2001. All Americans know what happened on Dec.7, 1941. What this movie does is take that historical event and put some flesh and bones on it. All the leads and supporting actors were in their early to mid20’s. Their performances are excellent and this movie propelled their careers sky high (Affleck, Beckinsale, Hartnett). What’s most notable about the performances is what they had to do to make one of the worst scripts in the world palatable. Without their skill in eye-acting and inflection, their characters would be flat and uninteresting. The standout performance belongs to Jon Voight as FDR. Alec Baldwin, like the young actors, makes his guts and glory dialogue more subdued. Randall Wallace, who wrote the screenplay for Braveheart and some other good films, butchers this one. Michael Bay, who directed, is his willing accomplice. The storyline focuses, not on the event itself, but on the fictionalization of real life people, the soldiers, sailors, and nurses who were stationed there. The love triangle is the plot point. It’s “the same ole story, a tale of love and glory.” Schmaltzy but endearing because of the talents of its young cast. And some scenes are truly romantic. The parachute hangar scene is my personal favorite 😏. These were the days before film makers required explicit sex to sell a love story. But back to the script. Here is what pilot #1 says to the girl he’s just met. “You are so beautiful.” Five second pause, same tone of voice, “You are so beautiful.” It’s like they forgot to edit out one of the two takes. He does it again with “I love you,” pause, “I love you.” Cringe! There is a lot of flag waving dialogue given to other characters, and, like the leads, these actors sell the cliches with their quality performances. We can nevertheless overcome this awful screenplay because the SFX are terrific. Watch the Director’s Cut that restores deleted scenes. The cinematography is jaw dropping. The aerial stunts are breathtaking. The cuts back and forth between stages in the attack, from Japanese military leaders to Navy intelligence personnel to FDR and his advisors, are nicely paced. Maybe I should have deducted a star for the truly weak writing, but so many other elements are so well done, Pearl Harbor gets all 5*