I finished the book not ten minutes ago and i would have given it five stars but they killed Fearless which is NOT OK Erin Hunter you need to fix this ok so instead when he saw Gallant Loyal and Swift he actually came back to life for killing Titan because killing Fearless is unacceptable because also he and Keen were an amazing ship and that ship never sailed so that also needs to be fixed and he was the main character so we got even more attached to him since we saw it from his point of view.