I think they should have competed against there own genre. The panel went with rap I I believe it was due to diddy. We need more R&B and that's my opinion but hey that dont matter in the music industry. James and whitney need to do a duet. Everyone goes through things in life and I feel that yall gave in cause of what she is going through. And yes she is going through a rollercoaster and she is blessed and extremely talented but I feel that James, whitney and sharaya J deserve a contract. James deserved to win cause he can sing