The Welsh Critic

Faith shaken, Not stirred: --------------------------------- Film directors Scott Becks' and Bryan Woods' 2024 film "Heretic" brings about a suspense-ridden story of two Mormon missionaries who visit the home of a mysterious man named Mr. Reed who kindly invites the two sisters into his home to discuss about religion. While he seems friendly, we can all see that the twisted events to come will make us say 'Don't judge a book by its cover'. I wasn't sure what to expect going into this film but I had a feeling it would have a sense of comedy in a horror film, considering how Hugh Grant as "Mr. Reed" was the main antagonist. After watching this film I believed (no pun intended) that the main thing that made the film all the better was its main actors + actresses. The two religious sisters played by Sophie Thatcher and Chloe East did a good job at 'playing the victim' in this film, thanks to the many uses of voice delivery which stood out and hit the right feelings in the right moments. Also, Grant did a good job playing "Mr. Reed" too and I think his natural humour mixed with the twisted character made the film all the more creepier as it evoked something sinister deep inside his character which is gradually revealed more as the film progresses. The only downfall that stands out to me in the film is the lack of originality and I guess I didn't experience the right horror element as it included more suspense than adrenaline-inducing scenes. I do like the tense scenes don't get me wrong, I just view that horror films should have a good balance between suspense and fright at the right moments. Building onto this, blending that balance into the storyline will definitely improve the film because it had potential in the plot but some scenes can be adjusted near the end of the film mainly. Before my final judgement, I would like to briefly appreciate the decent effects used in the film. The lighting and sets in "Mr. Reeds'" house felt strange and eerie in a good way because it matches the character. The basement set in the second half of the film felt alive and you will be able to tell, from that set compared to the rest of the house, that something bad or even the climax will happen there. However you can compare the similar silence that's lurking can be found throughout the majority of the film. Overall, I had a good time watching Grant's comedy and the tense scenes delivered between Thatcher and East as they seem to have followed the character's personalities and also the film script wonderfully. The major let-down is the failed attempt to create a believable plot and went off track of what the film should've been like. Apart from that, other factors makes the film slightly re-watchable. So, if you're a fan of the unexpected then this is the film for you thrill-seeking individuals. I hope you find this review helpful and inspirational, both audience and film-makers. Best regards, The Welsh Critic. Man