Great game. I'll say that Until Dawn was definitely scarier, but the story here was nice to unravel.
The actors were all great and compelling. (I'm not a fan of the monotone voice Justice Smith used throughout, but that's preference.)
Maybe I just don't find branching games to be incredibly difficult, but I thought I'd kill way more people during my first play through.
Giving 4 stars simply because for a horror game it wasn't that scary albeit some elements were creepy to say the least.