I’ve watched Chris Stuckmann’s reviews for perhaps a decade now, and I’ve always admired his passion for movies and filmmaking. Seeing him go from YouTube critic to professional filmmaker, I knew I had to support his debut film, Shelby Oaks.
This movie reminded me why you should never fully listen to critics before watching something yourself. I’d seen a few negative takes that made me nervous, but I’m glad I ignored them, because Shelby Oaks gave me a terrifyingly great time. It was just me and my brother at the screening, and while that was a bit sad (I wish more people went to see it), the empty cinema actually made the amplified the experience.
The movie starts strong, instantly pulling you into its mystery. It opens with a documentary-style, handheld feel that immerses you right away. The pacing was consistent, I never felt bored. Instead, it kept building tension and paranoia to the point where I started feeling watched. I found myself scanning the background of every shot, waiting to catch something lurking. The cinematography, performances, and direction were all impressive. The jump scares felt earned, not cheap, and the suspense built so effectively that at one point I just wanted the scare to finally happen.
The story was mostly strong, though I did find myself asking a few questions by the end. Still, it was more engaging and well thought-out than many thrillers or horror films made by bigger studios. You could really tell everyone involved cared about delivering quality. The “husband” character, however, seemed useless, I won’t go into detail, but he didn’t add much.
The third act gets a bit chaotic. There’s one particularly disturbing scene that genuinely unsettled me, and I’m still not sure if that’s a compliment or not. I also tend to prefer horror that stays grounded and mysterious, and Shelby Oaks leans a little too far into the over-the-top paranormal chaos near the end. It slightly pulled me out of what had been a wonderfully tense and believable build up.
You can sense the Mike Flanagan influence throughout, fitting, given Flanagan’s support for Stuckmann as a first-time director.
Overall, I thoroughly enjoyed Shelby Oaks. I’m not sure if it’ll have the same effect on a second watch anytime soon, but I’d fully recommend it. This is what horror should be about: suspense, earned scares, strong atmosphere, and a story that keeps you invested. Sure, it’s a bit of a mixed bag tonally, part documentary, part found footage, part mystery, part supernatural horror, but that’s also what makes it unique.
It’s not a perfect film, but it’s passionate, creative, and full of heart. For a debut, it’s deeply respectable, and it captures everything I love about horror.