I figured this one out a couple of episodes in. Some of the acting was pretty flat in the beginning. The community's lack of urgency in searching for a well-known missing resident seemed unrealistic. I probably wouldn't have stuck with it if Matt Bomer wasn't so pretty. Once I figured out what was actually going on, I found it to be totally predictable. I still can't quite figure out how supporting characters are so obtuse.
I suppose it's worth a binge on a rainy day if you've got 8 hours to kill. If not, skip it.