I agree with the many reviews that express itโs a sweet story, but not faith based.
The Miracle club is very secular in fact. I would not watch it with my Catholic grandma. This film could have easily been left secular without injecting Catholicism. It insults believers by portraying Catholics and people of faith in a very negative light. The story is really about people sharing a conflicting and overlapping past who are seeking hope, reconciliation, and miracles at Lourdes.
In their quest to receive an instant miracle they realize that Lourdes is more than a miracle factory. So it would have been best to let their own secular ignorance discover the beautiful history of Lourdes. And in so doing they find miracles which they werenโt seekingโฆ forgiveness, love, understanding. Ok so the latter is true to the movie. But the rest is set on the premise of a hypocritical, superficial, and dysfunctional Catholic culture. Which is not fair to the many devout Catholics, and Christians, who strive to live a Christ like life. Additionally, the Virgin Mary is very sacred to Catholics and demeaning her status is disrespectful.
I also donโt like the inference to the Catholic (and indirectly Christian) faith being fake and โa hoax.โ Imagine if they said that about any other religion or social group. It would not be tolerated. So many films today try to disparage Christian faith and build up secular believes. That is not consistent with the inclusivity Hollywood writers are trying to convey. So why the double standards? I recently saw another film that put a homosexual relationship on the pedestal, and I agree it was portrayed beautifully, but then came a part with a pastor and group of believers and they were portrayed as deceitful, foul mouthed, cannibals. I mean really, itโs quite obvious who Hollywood is for and against. They have a chance to unify, but choose to divide.