Alan Knight

Series one was AMAZING. Beautifully written, acted and filmed. It was compared to the first season of Broadchurch, and with good reason. Watching some of Britain's best actors in a tense mystery story is always going to be good. Sadly, like Broadchurch, they just had to try and wring a second series out of it and this is where it all went wrong. But where Broadchurch Parts 2 and 3 were only slightly muddled and dull, Keeping Faith falls entirely off the rails in the second series. Yes, you still have Eve Myles acting her heart out, which is great, but the story line is complete nonsense and the writing has lost everything that made the first series so good. Frankly, I wouldn't be surprised if the writer had simply handed the task of writing season two to Chat GPT and gone to the pub while it printed out. The result is a vague and half hearted script and a finished production full of lazy plot lines all flapping in the breeze. I avoided series 3.

Vaguely plotted mess of a film. All weird camera angles and music trying to give a creepy atmosphere. Unpleasant and annoying characters whose fate I couldn't care about. A complete waste of time.

I adore it. The switch to Jodie Whittaker in the lead role was just the shift the whole series needed. It felt like it's been spinning its wheels rather a lot in the last year or two so the new direction is very welcome.

It gets off to a cracking start then loses its way by the end. The final episode fizzles out completely, like the people making it lost interest. Bit of a disappointment.