Simon Watt

How are the scores so low for this? Absolutely love the opening as a snow fan.

First episode might put you off as not much going on, 2nd also if you've read the comic. After that this series is class but already gone the way of the Firefly.

Struggling to watch after 20 mins, dialogue seems to be straight from twitter and shoehorned in to make points, Can't tell if man or woman singing these days. Cop suspended cos racism untouchable subject. Quality actors just about keeping some charisma but I'm not seeing any other positives. I ever get through it may up the stars maybe?

Season 1 5/5 Season 2 3.5/5 Season 3 first half 2/5 second half (only 3 episodes!) hoping for the promised action, not seen yet. Most missing the spookiness of season 1. The overwhelming monsters and incredible action have been simplified to my recollection anyway. Ciri just not charismatic enough for a central role. I'll still watch it, so maybe too much moaning :)

Mostly usual great quality. What's with the 4 or so episodes in alternate universe "50's" town and Gar universe hopping. Dull, struggling to find enthusiasm to watch any more.

Jimmy Carr censored. Only watched one and half episodes so far but it's one political tone and no Jimmy Carr saying messed up stuff.

Episode 2. Some of this just passes me by, but the bit he goes back to his old estate and especially talks about his dad had me in stitches.

Very good show. Plot a bit too young teen aimed, not so much for my old self, and very similar in many ways to the excellent Magicians Guild book I'm reading right now (unknown girl magic user from the slums with lifetime boy friend trying to protect).

Season 3 excellent. I vaguely remember the last series was a bit of a turgid neoliberal dream for plot. This is a Trumpian nightmare , old vs young, alien chameleon overlords (sorry not lizard people). Great finale to ST:TNG , hopefully they will follow Picard with Seven (and hopefully I'll be in my twenties again!!)