This was the best $69 I ever spent in my life! I just got done designing my Room of Requirements the first time. It doesn't seem like it from the previews but the game is stunning!
The main story arc and quest is so strong-probably the best part about this game is the main storyline. And there's just so many details packed into all the locations -it's blowing me away. I love my character and it really feels like I'm in my own movie. (I thought it would feel like doing chores like the app game but it's like nothing else HP has produced).
You can do everything HP related here: fly brooms, make potions, go to classes, explore the grounds and the forbidden forest, shop at Hogsmeade, death party with ghosts, duel. Then there's so many clothing options that you pick up everywhere and pick up talents/skills which are beautifully illustrated.
The second best thing about the game is just the magical accents/like the movements for spells and the way the objects twist and turn. The effects are spectacular.
The third highlight is that the characters/people look so good in the Unreal Engine. It's my favorite rendering of people. The cinematic scenes are so nice.
Some of the fighting/enemies and sets reminds me of God of War (the reboot) while the wild areas remind me of Witcher. That's how tough it can get right from the start battling enemies. It caught me off guard. It doesn't feel like an RPG but really like a good open world.
The characters are actually charming though they could've been named better. I like them.
The only improvements for me: some of the hallways feel too ivy league college like therefore surprisingly mundane (maybe it's the classical music and marble), the kitchen was a bit dreary and let me down, imagined the forbidden forest/library to be different, but mostly: the map could look better and be easier to use. But there's an insane amount of detail that went into this game - it's magical that it exists and functions so well! 11/10 The best game I've ever played!!
Wish I could choose my own Patronus in a future game.
Update:
The season changed and now it's gorgeous fall in Hogsmeade and around Hogwarts.
OMG there's a mini game where you can remodel your own Room of Requirements (mine is very Beauty&TheBeast meets Sleeping Beauty like) which looks phenomenal and transfigure designs and colors and add props. I just had the best time cause it'll unlock a quest series where you can be like Newt Scamander and collect wild beasts and take them back to your own Vivarium. I even got a shiny Jabberknoll and am stoked to catch a niffler or unicorn next. You can collect pets basically and gather materials from them to upgrade your equip which is great cause I really like my go-to uniform. It made me realize just how large this map is- there's little communities I'm supposed to go to and now dens. Ive been flying my broom around (also upgradable) instead of exploring.
Wow they put so much work into this game!