I found the show to be quite entertaining some of the dialog could use a little bit more thought and care but overall I can't say it was a horrid show nor can I say it was perfect. I enjoyed the action and the interactions between character most of the time. It felt like not quite a return to form but a good step back to what it used to be when it had all the care and support. I will say though that I wanted to see more of the characters I knew doing stuff from the legends I know but I understand that can be difficult to do in a series like this.
Some of the plot being back and forth fetches and lookie here didn't help it but I again can't say it didn't fit in the vision as a whole. I love star wars I grew up with and want to see ut do well and draw a whole new generation of imagination and winder for a galaxy far far away there are things to work on but I have hope that with time Dave Filoni will come into his stride.
As for the other reviews here I have to shame most of them for hyper focusing one side or the other. They either emphasize the bad while ignoring the good or ignore the bad and emphasize the good. Yes the show had a lot of nostalgia but thats not inherently bad nor is it good how its used makes the difference. Do better, review better. It's not the show to save start wars but it's a least a step in the right direction.