7/10 - The best way to sum it up in one sentence? It's good, but only if you're a fan. So here's my actual consensus: It's a good movie if you know the Five Nights at Freddy's series, and you're going off the expectation that it's "break-in"/PG-13 Horror (most critics seem to have forgotten what series and age range this is).
Over time, I've realized that most of the critic reviews are accurate in that average viewers won't enjoy it because they don't know the series, but that's the same for something like Avengers: Endgame. But Endgame gets away with it because critics know to skip it if they don't know Marvel or the Avengers. The reason for this is likely that most Movie Critics who review the movie don't know or don't like the FNaF games; they still watch while not knowing the source material, while critics who don't know Marvel know to avoid Endgame.
So, who out of all Movie Critics will most likely review the Five Nights at Freddy's movie? Horror fanatics who don't know the difference between a FredBear and a Fazbear and who expect an actual horror film. Who is this movie for? The fans (not THE FAN, keep that thing away from me).