Peacemaker is arguably the most middle of the road show's I've seen and one of the most disappointing products of James Gunn's library. It has crazy great highs and absurdly low lows. For instance while I'm usually a fan of James Gunn's humor (i.e both GotG movies or The Suicide Squad which canonically precedes this). Whereas the humor in those was fast, witty, and most importantly funny, the jokes in Peacemaker are ok at best and cringy/dated at worst. I can very much hear Seth Rogen laugh when Peacemaker says "Superman has a poop fetish" or when one of the character's accidentally shares her gfs nudes with the group. Lets not forget about the HILARIOUS Powerpoint joke that doesn't last way too long at all, because thats what the kids are into these days right? Powerpoint? Jokes (literally) aside, the shows plot is pretty dang good, though I will say the first episode turned me off a little with the aforementioned hilarious jokes like "What if Peacemaker sang into a vibrator like a microphone? *Seth Rogen laugh*" But again the plot is very original and props to James Gunn for including more unheard of character's like Vigilante and other's who I will not spoil here, thats some nice fanservice right there. Also the theme song is amazing, once again James Gunn's OST knocks it out of the park.
To sum it up, I...guess I recommend this show? If it was all jokes then my rating would be lower but as I said earlier the story and the Soundtrack make up for the lack luster humor. (Now if only James Gunn would stop acting like this show is the magnum opus of superhero comedy and attacking those who say otherwise on IG)