I have read about 8 of Colleen Hoovers books so far and I loved them until I read this book. As others have said, it has the EXACT same dialogue between the two characters, nothing new. Occasionally you get a different perspective from holder where you can see some insight about his behavior in the first book but honestly, it could have been pure into hopeless as chapters from his perspective like she did in other books. It was like pulling teeth to finish it because it was boring. I enjoyed the ending like last 15 pages the most because it was newer material. Overall disappointed in losing hope but that’s ok.