If there is a film can make you cry and feel who would say it's not working? Yes a little bit of fumble in the screen play in the second half where there could have been lesser dialouges and more emotional exploration done. Couldn't get enough of the character Veer! By far really the most refined and matured character of Imtiaz Ali. But overall it is relevant, layered and beautiful! This movie will be the one you go back to a year later and love it again, just like Tamasha. The music especially Dhak-dhak and Haan Main Galat will go on your loop but the best song I think was Rahogi Meri.