It's really three stars, but the story is interesting, if unbelievable. None of these characters seems real. Why are the twins in the book anyway. Why did Julia not have more or any boyfriends in NY given that she was so beautiful and successful? Why did she not visit William in the hospital and what was so great about Sylvie's relationship with William. Why did anyone even like this guy? I am almost finished with it and I do want to see what happens at the end. Read Ann Tylor first.