The good
Very good game. The grind was enough to enjoy but not so in depth that it was overwhelming. The story was good. Dialog could have been better.
The bad
A lot of glitches. I don't play online, but that's how it felt. I would be moving and it would freeze for a sec and then resume. Even in some cutscenes you would see stuff floating because the table that was there couldn't be seen. I 100% completed the game, but not according to the progress menu and I know it's not just me because people were talking about this in forums. I would have red on my mini map and hear an enemy and there would be no one there or there would be "X's" on the map to pick up ears and they would stay there forever because there wasn't actually anything there.
All in all I really enjoyed this game, but it's way too long to play twice and that is saying something because I beat RDR2 twice. Lol.