I was really interested to play this game. I recently completed their latest (The Quarry) and had never heard of them before that.
The gameplay is clunky. The QTEs were unresponsive and I abhor the length you have to go to in order to gain some of the collectibles. Certain triggers have to have been met, certain folk need to be alive (or dead) and the slow movement makes me not want to play it again anytime soon (if indeed, ever). The gameplay is not explained well, in regards to the fact that it felt like I had missed parts of the story in some cases.
However, the idea behind the game, the effects and the thrill and scare factors do bring something to this game and so for that I am giving it a 3 star rating. I feel I do have to give it some breaks as it was the first game in the endeavour and after playing the second one - I can see where the improvements have been made. Looking forward to the upcoming releases.