First of all, everybody knows Bradley Cooper is a good actor and he is but as a director I don't think he did any good, as per the story it is very emotional but when you watch the film you don't feel such emotions. Next the main reason for me to watch the film was the hype of Lady Gaga's acting, we all know what a great musician she is but as an actor I think she is pathetic, her dialogue delivery, expression everything is so pale that it makes the movie so boring that you just wait for the ending. Songs are pretty good especially shallow, I don't think Lady Gaga should act till she improve by taking classes on how to express emotions through acting. Emma Stone would be a great help for Gaga and she should literally take some acting classes from her.