Calvin Yik

Hmm, starflight is cool I'm always sad he's being teased about even with his friends what's wrong with being smart? Nothing! It's just the setting and everything is boring or just not what I like that much.... *spoiler alert* I'm glad he told sunny his feelings! While this is a great book as well its not my fave

Loved it!! It isn't my absolute favorite but it's really good like all the other books! It's a great start. Plus cleril forever!

Honestly I was kinda disappointed. The third arc didn't have the same vibe as the first two because of the other continent thing but I really liked book 12 so I was hoping for a better 13. While I liked it I don't really like sundews point of view and willow is just so weird?...im not sure what to expect tho. I suggest not spending your money and just get it in the library or ur kindle so its less expensive.

Awesome! Wings of fire fans are gonna love it!

Yeah I'm giving this a 4 star and don't mind my name. I'm using my dad's account. Shh. Anyway I don't know why so many people like this book I mean I do too but it's so weird. Its so different from the first two arcs.... I found it slightly boring. Also more action and fighting please. Books 11 to 13 are mostly peaceful and blues with cricket, sundew is with willow. Why is there so much romance? Yeah they are cute and all but really? You guys don't have to agree with me but Im just sharing my opinion. Overall I liked this book too, just a bit disappointed. The first two arcs were amazing. This one is just so so

This book was awesome qibli was nice but why is he so perfect? And moon you're oblivious it's so obvious he likes you you weirdo. *Spoiler* Anyway I'm disappointed why the hell would you solve the problem like that? Well I wasn't sure how else it would be solved but erasing darkstalker seems like a bittersweet ending to me. It's weird. I'm wishing darkstalker listened and Idk maybe he turns good .. he was always good.. And then everything is at peace again. Something like that.

I LOVED IT ITS ONE OF MY FAVORITES IN THE SERIES!!! I wish tui didn't make winter so cold and like he's mean and heartless. I love winter...I'm always sympathising those who are... Idk. Anyway I loved this book so so much! Keep it up and anyone rooting for winter watcher? ... Yes he's harsh but it's because of his environment and how his tribe works I kinda hate the author for making him seem so bad its so unfair its just to make the decision of choosing qibli more realistic and easy. Honestly he's a good person see he did the human sanctuary thing and all, hes just afraid to show he's weak. Go winter. BTW I love winter time.