Absolute trash. I have loved every Bethesda and obsidian game and this just completely misses the mark.
Very boring, poorly written. Maybe 10 hours of actual content in the entire game that's worth pursuing. You get the choice of working for the cops, the military, or an evil corporation. And you have to be happy about it. The only alternative is that you can also work with a band of murderous marauders.
So while Skyrim and fallout 4 will have like 120 locations that you can go in, starfield has about 20 and they're very forgettable and generic. Kind of the whole point of the game is to reach New Game+ but if you didn't like the game the first time you're not going to like it the second time when you've almost completely deleted your progress and started over.
The settlement system that I liked so much in fallout 4 is barely present in this. The gunplay is boring and uninspired. The story is just a bunch of psychobabble that you're going to want to skip through. Some of the dialogue is so terrible that my face hurt from visibly cringing.