julianne – Google

My favorite Harry Potter book or Half blood prince i'm not sure haha, anyway amazing book i love how it (along with Half blood prince) has harry in the burrow for a lot of the book, plus i love the part when You-know-who comes back and overall i love it tbh when i first started reading Harry Potter, i thought it was really boring but after the first page i couldnt stop now im re-reading all of the books !!

I just want to point out something that i don't think anyone else really noticed. The time turners don't make any sense- in The Prisoner of Azkaban, Hermione went back in time with Harry yadah yadah yadah but- then Hermione (Just in the movie i think, or i missed it in the books) threw a rock at Harrys head and, back when they were in Hagrids house he felt it, so if Cedric's life really got saved than it would've been saved back when it actually happened. The same happened when Sirius was about to get the dementors kiss and Harry did the expecto patronum thingy, if what they did using the time turner didn't impact the past then Sirius would have actually died/got his soul removed and THEN Harry saved him when he used the time turner. So yeah that made 0 sense uhm plus they went back maybe.. a decade? Dunno, but if you went back in time you would have to age the time you went back- for example like if i went back in like 20 years i would have to live the 20 year before being back to the present day. Anyway very dumb haha, never actually read the book though 😃🔫 Though, based on the reviews here its pretty clear they made time turners completely different than the (much better) original series. Never plan on reading this book. Anyway just something i noticed maybe im wrong but yehahhh k thats all.