The best from House, the worst from ER.
Actually TGD has done a full circle, as it's from a Korean drama which itself is largely inspired from House and ER, so for those who likes House, it is somehow a refreshing and nice sequel to it.
With a clear reference to MD House, involving guest actors we really loved like Robert Sean Leonard in a hilarious episode with a Marlin stuck in his leg or Lisa Edelstein as an oncologist, or the soundtrack, TGD brings back good memories of House, such as the diagnostic process with a suspense that keeps the audience stuck to the screens.
Now it also gets its inspiration from ER and its bad tendency of getting rid off its characters or putting them thru a roller coaster of events that have little credibility. The problem with approach to me is the excess of drama twist the show into a crazy dark comedy. The actual mortality rate during surgery is around 3%, where in the show it is around 30%, plus the death of people surrounding the main characters, if not the main characters themselves, it is just too much. If anything, I would avoid their hospital!
Overall, we are still far from the level of creativity and filming talent from House. I wished they offered some good guest directors to shoot the show with 'start-from-the-end' or from a different perspective (ie: the nurses) to give us more insights on how an hospital works or how the dynamics between the characters works. But the matrix of Netflix/ABC is still great, with solid scripts, and great actors.
As always with Netflix, the film also pushes some messages and it questions our societies in their capacities to include the talents of people on a wider spectrum. And at least in the first 3 seasons that's great to finally have an angle where we include by merits and yes, where people have to prove themselves too, whatever their background. Equal chances for all, not forced quotas. Of course, I suspect the last seasons to be way more "Netflixed", and that's also why I am fine to stop after Season 3 as even though it's great to be inclusive, I don't really want to be forced-fed repeatedly on these points.
On autism, I read from over reviews that "the accountant" is way better, however I still think Dr Shaun Murphy makes me understand about autism. For instance, how we could interact and use their talents to contribute to a better society. Like anything, exposure is key to understanding and the show is great for developing empathy for Shaun and therefore for autism in general. My experience is limited, but now I understand better why this kid in the metro stared at me for 20 sec and then asked me: "are you a woman or a man?", which out of the blue can be very puzzling.
So I watched the 3 first seasons and stopped happily there as it concludes well this series with enough drama. Hope you enjoy the show too.