Ok all the CGI is good acting is alright along with the actual choreography of the fights but there are plenty of things wrong with the characters and the story, one galarial went with curufinwe to armor during the first age, the trees died and only could be restored by curufinwes silmarills (not mithril) sauron went to numenor once to destroy it which he did successfully he is also a mere vampire in thw first age, It feels really wrong to have part of the story to be the trees in the second age because that all happened in the first age and one again galadrial and her cousin elrond had nothing to do with it. I think they should have focused on unguliant and shelob. I know it's the rings of power but even at that that took place in the third age so overall VERY inaccurate but for a bad fan fic I give it a two.