A lot of people have lotted this game unfairly as one of the worst Lord of the Rings Video games. I disagree. It's certainly unpolished, and has a lot of flaws - like no autosave feature, the, at times, rigid dialogue - but it's still pretty damn fun to play. Many lot the console versions with the PC version, the most well known version. But there are many graphical improvements on the console versions such as improved less blocky looking character models whose mouthes don’t look like squares any more, or just hang open… but even then, it’s still a good game!
I love the combat mechanics on the Gamecube/PS2 version! It's super fun to switch between enemy targeting and free camera combat styles. I've played this game multiple times over the years, and each time I get more use to the controls. I love roaming around middle earth in linear styled open world levels, inspired by the Legend of Zelda no less. I never grew up on Zelda, so I never had experience with those games, so when I actually got to playing Ocarina Of Time and Majora's Mask, I was taken aback by how much I enjoyed aspects of The Hobbit more than those two games. Don't get me wrong, I really enjoyed Zelda, but there are game mechanics that The Hobbit, at times, excels at over those games. Basically, the combat is much more complex than what people give it credit for.
Many people’s criticism of this game Can be summed up as “it's too simple”, but it's a much shorter game than Zelda, and it's source material is in and of itself a simple story. One would definitely want more from this game, but what is there is of a substantial quality. It's a fun, comfort fiction, pulp-filled adventure thats short enough to pass the time on the weekend, it's also one of my favorite games.
I will say now though, as far as gripes, the last two levels are pretty weak, the second to last one especially. There's nothing wrong with a few puzzles sprinkled throughout, but this one is almost exclusively puzzles, and not the good kind...
Another thing that might've served this game well is a tutorial of the combat styles. I found myself not even knowing there was an auto targeting feature, or that to defend you need to auto target and walk backwards, until I fiddled around with the controls a bit. But that's in a long list of things this game could've done better.
Still, I can't deny I had, and still have, a lot of fun with this game to this day. Yes, I've played better games now these days, it is no where NEAR perfect, but I found myself enjoying this game more and more with time. Even after playing Games like God Of War, Horizon Zero Dawn, Breath Of The Wild, and Mario Odyssey, I find myself coming back to this odd piece of video game history, and just sitting an afternoon and playing it through. Stranger still is that I've probably played this game more times than any other game I've played over the years.