The stories are good, but they need to find more realistic monster costumes! It kind of ruins the whole thing when you're engaged in a story and then they reenact it wearing a cheesy gorilla suit that I could've bought on Amazon for $15.99.
I don't know how real the stories are, I've looked up a bunch of the "victims" telling their "true story", and it seems like most of them are actors. Oh well, it's still entertaining.