tracy elizabeth jones

I’m only 2.5 chapters in, and I’m beyond disappointed, as I really do Tana French, and was looking forward to this. I read The Witch Elm first and then plowed through the entire Dublin Murder squad series voraciously. They’re masterfully suspenseful and suck you in from the start. I’m so glad I didn’t read this one first or I would have missed out on the other seven books, which are some of the best reads in years for me. I’m not easily offended and I drop the occasional (probably more than occasional) f-bomb myself, so I have no issue at all with the worst of foul language in literature as long as it feels authentic and in-line with the character. And I haven’t made it far enough into the book to reach the point where the main character supposedly becomes cliche and laughable, so I can’t comment on what others have said at all in that regard. But my goodness this is the most boring work of non-fiction I can ever remember reading. Ive actually found myself finding other things to do at times when I would typically be reading as if I’m avoiding it. Most unlike me! And I’m sure some will take issue with me giving up on this story and writing a negative review only 2.5 chapters in, and I understand why they might feel that way. But let me say that no matter how delightful this story may become, if it feels arduous and effortful and unenjoyable for me to get to the good part, I’ll pass. I had to pause half way into chapter 3 to google reviews and see if I was missing something or if other people felt the way I do. I’m comforted to know I’m not alone. I say all of this with the utmost respect for the author and the writing process. I know the time and hard work and love that go into writing and creating, and I respect the hell out of anyone who puts their work into the world and opens themself up to this type of critique. My critique isn’t of the author, but of the story. And if you think I’m being overly harsh or rushing to judgement on this one, consider that I’ve never written an online review of anything in my life until today. BUT if this is your first Tana French novel and you aren’t impressed with it either, I hope you will give her another chance (or seven). You really can’t go wrong with the others, in my opinion. She is a fabulous storyteller and writer. I’m eager for her next book, but in the meantime, I’m onto something else.