Not a single thing in this movie was relatively close to the books. Thomas is way to old, the spook was against killing witches, the spook did not drink did not live in a cave, but in a nice house surrounded by gardens, and witches did not turn into dragons And most importantly key characters are missing or wrong! As a huge fan of the books this movie is horrible. And I know no movie is ever exactly like the book but none of them should be completely different from them