Tbh wattpad books did it better. If you’re willing to play the king game for the good parts you have the right book. It was a cute story I listened to it as in audiobooked. I understand that why sophomore 15 yr girls love this book along w 23 yr girls. I like diary youth parts. With each chapter I had a lot to say about a lot. You’ll pick off if your lost and get confused real quick! I understand the hype As a 17 year old I give it a 5/10 for the atlas romance if only atlas would have been brothers with Ryle. For Ryle being so confident he should have been in the mafia or doing something sketchy j to give him a more assertive outlook on his character. He framed unsure in life and lily was his sureness yet he’s not shy??? This books characters were contradicting. Much luv! No hate :) (p.s. stop making exuses for Ryle and be w Atlas Lily):