Just finished the book 20 minutes ago and god I was hooked. Got it delivered with the one of us is lying series in the morning and I just couldn't put it down! Being a true crime stories fan myself I couldn't relate more with Ellery with her theories and the suspicious nature of her, all the characters are so well portrayed and with chapter you'll feel whole new set of emotions and changed feelings for them and I am all in for it. The only reason for me giving it a four star is how the end becomes a bit predicatble, I did read for most it was not and that they didn't see it coming, but guess the foreshadowing was a bit obvious if you actually thought and see between the lines ( specially the time when Sadie's boyfriends were being mentioned). other than that story is amazing in all aspects just guess the end could have been a but more extended and a bit better understanding fror Sarah's part but still totally loved the book. Definitely a must read for new thriller readers!