I liked it, butter than Ahsoka and The Mandalorian by a mile. I think most who don't were too exposed to the bad press prior to the show release. The characters were interesting and nuanced and well acted. The episodes could have been longer. The story is good, although they spent too long on some things and not enough time on others. I appreciate that it explores more grey area than star wars usually does, showing us force users who don't subscribe to the light/dark side dichotomy, and suggests that hoarding power and controlling others, no matter for what good intent, has inherent flaws and invites challenge.