It's hard for simple minded people to give this 5 stars because they didn't understand the underlying themes and emotion brought to the game. The Last of Us isn't about any 1 character in particular as you play through the first game and second, it's about the last of us (as in the remnants of humanity after the outbreak).
The people complaining about Abby's body; they're the superficial types of people.
The people complaining about a characters death; the misogynists.
People need to think a little harder on the symbolism throughout the entire game.
I believe this game deserves GOTY or GOTG