The book is good but not really that good it's in the good but just barley the ending makes its worse early on in the book its established that all the kelpies have to go back to the ocean and can only be sent to here if the have a mission to there family but we see at the end another Kelpie is there so I'm like why haven't you gone back to the sea and yay I agree the main character doesn't really have all that in terms of personality and yay the story is unrealistic with the romance where they have the chapters meet once as kids and then instantly be in love and the main character is tiny bit of a moron but other then that story isn't that bad two and one half of three stars.