Rory Gilmore: She cheated on her boyfriend, screwed up a job interview because she thought she deserved better, and was a terrible journalist who only wanted to make herself look good.
Sookie St.James: she'd never randomly just leave for a year, they should've asked the actress to be in the whole thing. Melissa's feelings were even hurt that they took so long to ask her to do the little that she did.
Lorelai and Luke: they either should've already had another child that we just didn't see happen or not have wanted more children because they're kind of old to do that now.
Emily Gilmore: I mean, everything she did was uncharacteristic for her. I don't really buy that she'd ever be happy working at a museum but whatever.
Luke Danes: he'd NEVER even get wifi so that whole thing with the fake passwords was just stupid. Luke is too smart to even get wifi.
Paris: the whole freak out at Chilton was ridiculous because she got over Tristen a long time ago and she definitely wouldn't have freaked out at Francie.