Uh...yikes. I have no words for this movie. I was expecting so much more. The concept of a wishing star in Disney has already been elaborated on in The Princess and the Frog (a better homage to Disney) and older concept art of Star, who takes on a humanoid form, (and a much better design) has been changed to a star looking like a marketable plushie. The animation is very flawed, the lighting is off, making it look unfinished. The music is just generic and forgettable, Rosas is a stereotypical Disney town that's nothing out of Disney's comfort zone, and so many characters-oh god, the characters-are very controversial.
Magnifico has good reason to keep these wishes as a means of preventing someone from realizing that they'll never have their wish granted. It's not great to make them forget their wishes, but a much more passive solution. The villain motto was just forced on him to make him appear awful and horrible just because he reasonably won't grant a wish that may just be endangering his town. Disney villains are compelling, maybe corny at times, but still pose a serious threat and let you know that they're a villain. Magnifico does not steal wishes, villagers willingly give their wishes to him. They're in his power and he decides what to do with them.
Star could have been great. Asha could have been great. Her design is regal and poised, but she is just an overly quirky heroine. Valentino? I...hated that goat. Just built entirely off comic relief without actually belonging in this world and furthering the plot. Most other characters besides the main cast are utterly forgettable except for Dahlia.
Overall, this is just a disappointing movie that does not feel like a celebration of 100 years of Disney and just feels like an expected and generic film.