I love Sherlock games and picked this one because it was the same characters as the Crimes and Punishment one, same type of gameplay. I enjoyed it. The reason for my 3 stars, is where crimes and punishment was 6 cases, this one was just one long drawn out case. The other reason was sometimes having to google what to do because a lot of times it was not obvious. I dont mind a little brainpower being used, but the amount of times i didnt know what to do, almost made me give up playing. Despite that being said, i did enjoy the game.