If one sees this movie through a realistic eye then probably it could be realized that this film has the most sensible ending which most people seem to protest against. To me the approach of the film was challenging but never did it encourage people similar to Will Traynor to take the same decision. Most people like Will do not share the same mindset, experience, environment (and sarcasm ) after all... so it's quite safe to say that this film, instead of featuring a universal community's actions or decisions, is based on a heartwarming and a unconventional love story of two people coming from opposite directions of life and merging beautifully into one. I learned one thing from this movie that maybe some things in life are good, great even, but there may come a time when they don't matter. Nevertheless, many will disagree with me at this point but to be frank, I LOVE THIS FILM, THE WHOLE OF IT. So I will request whoever views this post to give this film a try. Don't be saddened or joyous by any of the reviews because they,I think, are based fully on the writer's point of view. Lots of love and if possible, try the book. It's heavenly.