A literary work rich in symbolism and deeply layered in its portrayal of issues such as identity, history, literature, and socio-cultural conflicts. The novel is not merely a narrative of events or historical facts but a profound analysis of the shared history between Turks and Armenians. Its plot seamlessly weaves together the past and the present, revealing contradictions and reflecting how deeply history influences the present.
As always, Elif Shafak excels in transitioning between past and present. Her symbols are captivating and intriguing (such as food, places, names, and more), alongside her precise descriptions of scenes, locations, and characters. She compels the reader to ponder many questions.
The novel is an invitation to reconcile with oneself and with the other, emphasizing shared human understanding across cultures and peoples. The characters are deeply portrayed, each carrying a wound or a question from the past or present. The ending of the novel serves as a pivotal and unexpected turning point when the author reveals Asya’s father. During his first visit back to Turkey after spending twenty years in America fleeing his past, he meets his end in his family home. Ironically, this is the same house where he raped his sister. His death comes at the hands of his eldest sister, who, out of pity, believes he cannot bear the burden of his past. She was the only one who knew the secret of Asya’s father, having learned it from her Jinn friend, Petar!